Home > HR compliance > Employment law updates > Long week, short pay, no go, says appellate court
Employee taking notes on the latest HR compliance news.

Long week, short pay, no go, says appellate court

Employers can’t get around the overtime requirements by decreasing employees’ regular rate of pay as the length of their workweek increases, a new appellate court ruling shows.

|

Read time

1–2 minutes

|

Share this:

Written by:

Read time

1–2 minutes

Share this:

Written by:

Share

Employers can’t get around the overtime requirements of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) by decreasing employees’ regular rate of pay as the length of their workweek increases, a new appellate court ruling shows.

Employers may lawfully reduce employees’ weekly average rate, but only if the reductions are not an attempt to avoid or limit overtime costs. The key consideration is whether a change “is justified by no factor other than the number of hours” an employee works.

In Thompson v. Regions Security Services, Inc., the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals found there was enough evidence to conclude that a Florida-based company may have reduced one of its employees’ non-overtime hourly rate to avoid paying him overtime.

The employee was hired at a rate of $13.00 per hour and initially worked for 40 hours per week. Then his employer started scheduling him to work roughly 60 hours per week and soon lowered his rate to $11.15 per hour. As a result, his overtime rate became $16.725 per hour (one and one-half times his regular rate of pay) and he earned $780.50 per week (40 straight-time hours at $11.15 (or $446.00) plus 20 overtime hours at $16.725 (or $334.50)). That turned out to be only 50 cents more than he would have earned if he were paid his former $13.00 per hour rate for all 60 hours of work.

This arithmetic, combined with the employee’s allegations that his employer went back to paying him $13.00 per hour after it stopped scheduling him for overtime, supports the “reasonable inference” that the employer had lowered his hourly rate to avoid paying him overtime, the 11th Circuit reasoned.

It sent the case back to a lower court for further proceedings.

Michael Cardman

Written by:


Navigate HR complexity with confidence

With Brightmine, you can build powerful people strategies, implement best practices and set your organization up for a brighter future.

Learn how our tools, resources and automation can empower you and your team.

You may also be interested in…

Charts

Minimum wage rates by state and municipality

Need clarity on minimum wage rules? Our comprehensive 50‑state chart helps HR teams track state and municipal wage …

HR law guides

New York payroll and wage payment compliance for employers

This guide explains New York wage payment requirements, including the definition of wages, payment methods, pay frequency, permitted …

Charts

Airport minimum wage requirements by state

Our 50-state chart for minimum wage compliance for airports helps HR and payroll teams quickly understand where airport‑specific …

Topics on this page


About the author

Senior Legal Editor

Areas of expertise: Wage and hour compliance, Minimum wage law, Overtime law, Employee classification, HR compliance for independent contractors, Child labor law

Sign up to receive expert HR insights from Brightmine

    LNRS Data Services Limited and its affiliates may contact you about relevant solutions, services, events and industry insights. You can opt-out via the unsubscribe link in the communications that you receive or by contacting us.