Home > HR compliance > Discrimination > Recruiting on “gut feeling” led to unconscious racial bias
Person sitting at a desk, holding a pen and looking at a laptop while writing in a notebook.

Recruiting on “gut feeling” led to unconscious racial bias

A discrimination case examining how reliance on “gut feeling” in recruitment decisions led to findings of unconscious racial bias.

Share this:

appointment process | unconscious bias | race discrimination

In James and another v London & Quadrant Housing Trust, an employment tribunal upheld race discrimination claims brought by two housing managers after finding that they had not been appointed to senior roles because of the trust’s unconscious bias. The tribunal was critical of the employer’s reliance on “gut feeling” in the appointment process, highlighting the risks of subjective decision‑making where clear criteria and evidence are lacking. The case underlines the importance for employers of structured, transparent recruitment processes and objective assessment when making appointment decisions.

Want to see more?

For full access, sign up to a HR and Compliance Centre subscription today.

Navigate HR complexity with confidence

With Brightmine, you can build powerful people strategies, implement best practices and set your organisation up for a brighter future.

Learn how our tools, resources and automation can empower you and your team.

You may also be interested in…

Commentary and Insights

Reintegration after incarceration: Challenging the workplace stigma against ex-offenders

People leaving prison continue to face significant barriers to employment, despite the skills and resilience many bring to …

Commentary and Insights

No bad intent required: How unconscious gender bias shapes leadership progression

Understand how vague leadership criteria and stereotypes shape leadership outcomes and contribute to unequal progression for women.

Employment law guide

Disability discrimination: Definition of disability

A guide explaining how disability is defined under the Equality Act 2010 and who is protected from disability …

Topics on this page


About the author

Brightmine

With more than 10,000 customers, Brightmine is a leading global provider of people data, analytics and insight – empowering HR leaders to deliver brighter business outcomes.

For more than two decades, Brightmine, formerly XpertHR, has continued to help HR leaders confidently navigate the evolving world of work through our unique combination of critical workforce data, AI-enabled technology and trusted HR expertise.

Brightmine is a division of LexisNexis Data Services within RELX®, a global provider of information-based analytics and decision tools. RELX serves customers in 180+ countries with 35,000+ employees. Ticker: London: REL; Amsterdam: REN; New York: RELX.

Sign up to receive expert HR insights from Brightmine

Join our community and stay updated with industry trends, expert insights, valuable resources, webinar invites… and much more.

Sign up now and receive regular updates straight to your inbox!

    LNRS Data Services Limited and its affiliates may contact you about relevant solutions, services, events and industry insights. You can opt-out via the unsubscribe link in the communications that you receive or by contacting us.