Two professionals seated at a desk reviewing documents together next to a laptop in a modern office.

How to conduct a pay review

Learn how to conduct a fair and effective pay review with practical HR guidance to support transparency, consistency, and strong performance management.

Share this:

By Sarah Welfare

The pay review – also known as a pay settlement or award – is one of the basic building blocks of reward and the majority of organisations carry one out each year. They can vary from a cost-of-living increase for all employees negotiated with a trade union to a finely differentiated range of individual increases based on performance, market rates or progression.

Employers may award the same pay increase to all employees at their organisation, or may choose to differentiate between different employee groups (also known as bargaining groups). The pay review process may also include a review of benefits, and other terms and conditions.

While employers take a whole range of factors into account in deciding their pay review – from inflation to comparable rates in the local labour market – affordability will be the biggest concern for most and sometimes a review may result in no pay increase. But even when only a small pay rise is possible, the annual pay review can still provide an opportunity for the organisation to put its reward principles into practice, both through outcomes and through the way the review is carried out.

In this guide, learn about:

  • Objectives
  • Planning, responsibilities and timetable
  • Pay review date
  • Duration
  • Process overview
  • Negotiated pay reviews
  • Setting the budget
  • Types of pay review
  • Factors to take into account
  • The cost of living
  • Market rates and salary surveys
  • Comparable pay awards
  • Performance-based awards
  • Using a pay matrix
  • Reviewing the pay structure
  • Other elements of the pay and benefits package
  • Pay freezes and cuts
  • Checking for equality issues
  • Employee communication
  • Transparency
  • Learning for next time

Want to see more?

For full access to How to conduct a pay review, sign up to a HR and Compliance Centre subscription today.

Navigate HR complexity with confidence

With Brightmine, you can build powerful people strategies, implement best practices and set your organisation up for a brighter future.

Learn how our tools, resources and automation can empower you and your team.

You may also be interested in…

Podcasts

Pay reviews in 2026 – balancing budgetary pressures and employee expectations

What do pay reviews look like in 2026? Explore key trends shaping reward decisions as employers balance cost …

Press releases

Pay trends 2026 | March Report

Discover the latest UK pay trends for March 2026. Despite a boost for first pay deals of 2026, …

Employment law guide

How to design, introduce and run a performance-related pay scheme

A guide explaining how to design, introduce and operate a performance‑related pay scheme, including legal, contractual and equality …

About the author

Sarah Welfare

Sarah Welfare was formerly an HR practice editor at Brightmine, with responsibility for content on pay, benefits and international HR.

Sarah has more than 15 years’ experience in the HR/employment field, having worked on both sides of industry at the CBI and then at the Amalgamated Engineering and Electrical Union. After that, she was employment policy director for the Equal Opportunities Commission, where her main role was to promote the use of equal pay audits in the private sector.

Start your free trial today

Register today to gain free 7-day access to the Brightmine HR & Compliance Centre and stay up to date, compliant and save valuable time